384 Relax and Succeed Rebuttal - A promise should be

Hmmm. I see Frank’s stuff on line and I know he’s a caring person with high character. But with no disrespect intended, I’ve gotta disagree on this one. Because what does should’ mean? I mean in practice?

The word should’ is kind of like a wish. It’s us deciding to live with an expectation that another person will do exactly what we think they should do.

We’re willing to do this because historically we are right far more often than we are wrong. This is the case for the vast majority of people and this is for two reasons:

One; our friends are just the people who agree with how we see the world, so they’ll also usually do what we would do.

Two; to live in a society is to live within a framework of agreed-upon boundaries for behaviour, be those laws, rules, customs or even etiquette. However it’s important to remember that in reality people routinely break laws, disobey rules, ignore customs and defy etiquette. So should’ is just a wish.

Hoping someone keeps a promise is a wish. If we’re going to get mad every time one of our wishes doesn’t come true then we are in for one painful life. Because we will all, without trying to, break lots of promises in our life simply because life is complex and it  was never designed to be perfected.

Sometimes life’s complications can lead good people to take uncharacteristic action (or inaction) and that can be a very painful experience. And we can end our relationships with anyone who lets us down. But that is likely to lead us to be alone.

Far better than being absolute is to be forgiving and flexible. After all, there is a 100% chance that we’ll need that wiggle room too. 

peace. s

00 Relax and Succeed - Other Perspectives Footer